• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Fermenting for Foodies

Health, Taste and Tradition

  • Fermentation
    • General Information
    • Beans, Nuts & Seeds
    • Beer, Wine, & Cider
    • Dairy & Cheese
    • Fermented Fruit
    • GF Sourdough
    • Trad Sourdough
    • Probiotic Beverages
    • Vegetables
    • Supplies
  • Healthy Meals
    • Appetizers
    • Baked Goods
    • Breakfasts
    • Condiments
    • Main Dishes
    • Sides & Salads
    • Soups & Stews
    • Desserts
    • Gluten-Free
    • Vegan
  • Fruit-Sweetened Treats
  • Cookbook

How to Choose the Best Probiotic Supplement?

How to choose the best probiotic supplement
How to test your probiotic supplement for effectiveness
Three things to look for when buying probiotic supplements
What are the best probiotic supplements

Antibiotics and antibacterial cleaners play a major role in preventing serious illnesses. Unfortunately, they also kill beneficial strains of bacteria leaving our microbiome weak and vulnerable. Here is a brief guide on how to choose the best probiotic supplement for gut health and wellness.

Probiotic supplements are found at most grocery stores, health food stores, and pharmacies. The only trick is that they are often quite expensive, and it’s hard to tell whether they are actually effective. Here are some things to consider when buying a probiotic supplement.

How to choose the best probiotic supplement

When buying a probiotic supplement, you can choose between tablets & capsules, refrigerated or not. Here are 3 simple rules for choosing high-quality probiotic supplements:

  • Avoid probiotic products that are heavily processed. The point of processing foods is to make them shelf-stable. So skip the probiotic chewing gum and probiotic snacks.
  • Tablets are less likely to have live bacteria, so choose gel caps or liquid supplements instead. 
  • Live bacterial supplements should be stored in the refrigerator or freezer. Like all probiotic products, if a supplement is shelf-stable then it’s probably not filled with live culture.

Test your probiotic supplement

The best way to make sure a probiotic supplement contains lots of live bacteria is to test it out. Most probiotic supplements contain bacterial strains that will culture in milk. Even a supplement that contains a lot of different strains of bacteria will contain some strains that will culture in milk.

Whether you use vegan milk or regular milk, follow the use yogurt-making procedure using the probiotic supplement as the culture. Most tablets, capsules, and powders claim to contain billions of bacteria, so they should readily culture in 2 cups of milk within 24 hours. If after 24 hours you don’t have a really tangy yogurt then it is not a good supplement.

Snake Oil?

Despite all of this advice, I generally don’t recommend buying a probiotic supplement. I have tried to culture several very expensive brands of probiotics without any luck. One of them was a purchased liquid supplement through my naturopathic doctor, and despite containing several strains of yogurt-loving bacteria, it wouldn’t culture in milk.

I’m not alone with my dismal findings of the ineffectiveness of probiotic supplements. This British Study tested 8 different brands of probiotics with very little success. At this point, I think you would have better luck growing sea monkeys.

Grocery store probiotics: yogurt, kefir, kombucha and more

Instead of buying an expensive probiotic pill, improve your gut health with probiotic foods. While I always recommend making your own fermented foods, there are a number of probiotic foods that can be found in the grocery store.

Avoid:

  • Any probiotic foods that are not in the freezer or refrigerator. Probiotics that are alive will not be shelf-stable.
  • Kefir and kombucha are effervescent when they’re alive. If the container is sealed when you buy it, then it is no longer living. Even if it is bubbly… a sealed bottle of kombucha isn’t alive. There are too many risks involved with sealing live kombucha (exploding bottles, alcohol production, a super sour product).
  • In fact, I would say MOST generic grocery store kombucha isn’t alive. There are some exceptions, for example, there are kombucha brewers selling to hippy grocery stores in my city. So beware, most grocery store kombucha is just soda pop dressed up as a health product.

Buy:

  • Yogurt! All yogurts have some live culture, though they do vary greatly on how “alive” they are.  In my Canadian neck of the woods, I like Astro’s BioBest and Greek Gods, which both have very active cultures.
  • Try other cultured dairy products like buttermilk, sour cream, kefir (it’s usually not real kefir, but it does have Lacto-bacteria living in it).
  • Refrigerated fresh products like miso, sauerkraut, and kimchi will also be probiotic. It depends on what is being made in your region, but you may be able to find all sorts of live probiotics. Usually, these are expensive, which is a good reason to try making a few DIY probiotics.

Filed Under: Cornerstone, Healthy MicrobiomeTagged With: Probiotic, Science

Previous Post: « Vegan Reuben Sandwich with Tempeh
Next Post: Carrot Salad with Miso Dressing »

Reader Interactions

Related Posts

6 Benefits of fermented foods and beverages
6 Benefits of Fermented Foods and Beverages
How to feed your microbiome a healthy gut diet
Feed Your Microbiome A Simple Healthy Gut Diet
Why fermented foods are a good source of probiotics
5 Reasons Why Fermented Foods Are The BEST Probiotics

How to test if store-bought kombucha is probiotic
Is Store-Bought Kombucha Probiotic?
The science behind good immunity
12 Ways To Naturally Boost Your Immune System
How to filter water to remove chlorine and chloramine
How to Filter Water for Gut Health and Fermentation

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

Hi, I'm Emillie, an island-dwelling fermentation enthusiast. Fermenting For Foodies features healthy recipes designed to feed your microbiome.
Read More →

Check Out My Cookbook!

Fermenting Made Simple Cookbook

Want healthy recipes right to your inbox? Subscribe to our mid-month newsletter!

Thank you!

Please check your inbox to confirm your subscription.

Affiliate Disclosure

In order to run this site, Fermenting For Foodies sometimes earns an affiliate commission on the sales of products we link to. We only feature items we genuinely want to share, and this is an arrangement between the retailer and Fermenting For Foodies. Readers never pay more for products. Thank you for reading!

  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Affiliate Disclosure
  • Sponsored Content
  • Contact

Copyright © 2023 · Fermenting for Foodies